Thursday, November 12, 2026

Biblical Analysis of scriptures used in abortion arguments

Scriptures used for the Pro-Choice argument

Exodus 21:22-23  This passage presents a scenario where two men are fighting and a pregnant woman is accidentally struck.  The woman is not hurt but depending on the translation the baby is either the victim of a miscarriage or born premature but alive.  The Hebrew word in question here is yasa and means to go or come out.  Frequently, yasa is used in the Old Testament to render a live birth.  This may be irrelevant to this argument since this scripture is not referring to an intentional act of killing the unborn.  Those that use this scripture to support a pro-choice argument usually say that verse 23 shows that the unborn are not given the same rights as those outside of the womb.  This understanding would require the translation of yasa as a miscarriage or abortion but since verse 22 clearly depicts an accident it wouldn’t be a murder but simply an accident or an equivalent of involuntary manslaughter which doesn’t carry the same penalty as murder.  It is not a statement on the value or rights of a person but instead a statement on the intentions of those that caused the event.

Jeremiah 20:14-18 In this passage Jeremiah is lamenting that he was ever born.  He expresses a wish that he had been aborted, having his mother’s womb as his grave.  The error in using this as scripture for pro-choice is that it assumes that an expression desiring that one had been aborted is declaration that abortion is morally permitted but this text doesn’t go that far.  He wonders why he was born just to end his life in shame but we know that Jeremiah’s life did not end in shame.  His reason for desiring that he had been aborted was shown to be wrong.  What this scripture does do, though, is speak of the unborn as a person. 

Ecclesiastes 6:3-5  and Job 3:16-19 Like the passage from Jeremiah we have an account of a person lamenting life and questioning if it is better to never have been born.  This does not promote or support abortion but questions whether or not it can be better to never have been born than to not be able to enjoy the fruits of life or find rest and security from the wicked.

Numbers 5:11-31 This passage is about a test to determine if a wife has been unfaithful. The test consists of drinking a potion and the effect the potion has on the wife will determine if she was guilty.  There really was nothing “magical” about the potion.  The priests knew that it would be God that would be revealing guilt or non-guilt, not the potion.  If she was not guilty she would be unaffected and able to conceive children.  If she was guilty the penalty would be that “her belly would swell and her thigh will shrivel”.  That seems to be some sort of euphemism.  It seems to mean that she will become sick and no longer be capable of conceiving children.  That was her curse.  That would seem to be a conclusion consistent with the statement in the passage that if she was not guilty she would be able to conceive children.  All the translations I can find translate it this way except one – the NIV.  It says that the potion will cause the guilty to have a miscarriage.  From that some people find an angle to make this about abortion. That seems to be out of line though.  The passage never says the woman was even pregnant.  This was about finding if the wife was guilty of infidelity, regardless of whether or not she got pregnant from it.

 

Scriptures used for the Pro-Life argument

Psalm 22:10, Luke 1:15 and Luke 1:41 These verses are used by some pro-life advocates to show the personhood of the unborn in the womb.  I do not think that is the intent the Psalmist or Luke had.  These verses seem to me to be figurative and\or hyperbolic speech.

Exodus 20:13  This is the command from the 10 commandments against murder.  I do believe abortion is murder but I do not believe this verse can be used as an argument against abortion unless the unborn in the womb is first shown to be a live human.  I believe this can be done using my argument from human rights but I don’t think that the scripture by itself stands as an argument against abortion. [see my article “Abortion – an unnecessary violation of human rights”]

Although I do not believe we have scripture that directly addresses abortion I do believe we can find the views of the earliest Christian church by writings outside of the Bible.  For example, The Didache, a Christian writing dated to the 1st century states “you shall not murder a child by abortion”.

 


 

Abortion – an unnecessary violation of human rights

One of the most contentious topics of our lifetimes is the topic of abortion.  Mud-slinging and stereotypes fly from both sides with no end in sight.  In this article I will attempt to give a reasoned, non-emotion fueled, look at this issue.  My approach will be one of a human rights perspective.  I will present a deductive argument that I believe is logically sound and conclusive and then expand on each premise.  If the premises are true, then the conclusion (#5) necessarily follows.

Deductive Argument

1.       The ultimate, most fundamental human right is the right to life.  Without life a human can have no other rights.

2.       The being in the womb is a living human from the moment of conception.  It doesn’t matter if we call it an embryo, fetus, baby or “product of conception”, it is human. Embryo, fetus, etc. are stages of human development, not stages of developing into a human.

3.       This being in the womb is innocent of any wrongdoing.  It had no choice in its conception and has violated no laws – civil, criminal nor moral.

4.       Abortion extinguishes the life of an innocent human.

5.       Therefore, abortion robs an innocent human of the most basic human right.

Premise 1:  I believe this is self-explanatory.

Premise 2:  From the point of conception, the being in the womb has a complete set of human genetic material.  It has its own DNA that is distinct from the mother.  The genetics are distinctly human.  It is not developing into a human.  It is a human in the earliest stages of human development.  It will never be anything other than human.  [see References 1, 2, and 3 at the end of this article]

Premise 3:  I don’t think this needs further explanation.

Premise 4:  The various usages of the term “abortion” can make this a bit confusing.  For the purposes of this argument (and in most state laws that I have seen) what is meant by “abortion” is the intentional termination of the human life growing in the womb.  Procedures that are used in the cases of miscarriage are often medically coded as “abortion” but that is not an intentional termination of a human life.  In a miscarriage, the human life is already deceased.  I am not opposed to medical procedures that safely remove the already deceased unborn.

Premise 5:  Given the truths presented in premises 1-4, the conclusion of premise 5 is necessarily true.

If it could be shown that the being in the womb is not human from the point of conception, I would not oppose abortion up to the point at which it becomes human.  At the present time, though, the evidence seems to say that it is human at conception.

Rape and Incest

With this reasoning stated we can look at the situations of rape or incest.  How would these situations change the argument above?  I don’t think it changes any of the premises.  What is different is the context in which the conception took place but it does nothing to change the argument above of why abortion should not take place.  If we were to accept the argument above, but make exceptions in cases of rape or incest, we would be saying that a conception from rape or incest produces a being that is not human.  That is not what takes place though.  The being in the womb from rape or incest is every bit as human as the being in the womb that results from a planned pregnancy.

The argument to allow abortion in the case of rape or incest is usually based on the emotional trauma that can be experienced by the victim.  This emotional trauma is real and cannot be ignored and can also lead to physical problems.  This trauma is a result of the rape or incest, not the pregnancy.  There will still be trauma after an abortion.  An abortion will not wipe away the trauma from the rape or incest.  An abortion might even increase the trauma.  It depends on the person.  The victim is going to need a strong support group and probably some good counseling regardless of whether or not an abortion is permitted.

Going back to my deductive argument which is based on human rights, in the case of rape or incest, we are placing a human right to life vs a human right to emotional health.  Premise #1 is that the ultimate, most fundamental human right is the right to life.  That should win out over the human right to emotional health.  It’s not going to be easy for the rape victim but at least they have a chance to go on to have a productive life.  The abortion victim never has that chance.

Abortion to Save the Life of the Mother

Some argue that abortion is necessary in some emergency cases to save the life of the mother.  If such a scenario arises it would be a case where we should do all we can to save lives.  Our goal would be to save both lives if possible.

Do these scenarios actually exist, though?  In cases where emergency treatment is needed it would be important to act quickly.  These cases would typically be in the 2nd or 3rd trimester where it can take 36 to 48 hours to prepare the patient for the procedure.  This would not be useful in an emergency.  There are better options.  [see Reference 4 at the end of this article]

Ectopic pregnancy is often cited as a situation that requires abortion but that is just incorrect.  The procedure for treating an ectopic pregnancy is not abortion. [see Reference 5 and 6 at the end of this article]

Personhood

Some people suggest that we should be focusing on personhood instead of human rights.  There is no clear definition of personhood though.  It is very subjective.

Some have suggested that the determination of personhood should be self-awareness and\or capability for rational thought.  On a quick glance this sounds reasonable but then what about infants and some mentally handicapped, both of which would fail this definition?  This would be an example of a defining property that cannot be held consistently.

Some have argued for “viability” as the gauge for personhood and this has been used in some legal definitions but viability is a measure of technology and not personhood.  As technology increases the age of viability has and will continue to decrease.

References

1.       National Library of Medicine, Fall 2021, “The Scientific Consensus On When Life Begins”

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36629778/

2.       American College of Pediatricians, March 2017, “When Human Life Begins”

https://acpeds.org/when-human-life-begins/

3.       NPR, November 22, 2005 “A Distinct Human Organism”

https://www.npr.org/2005/11/22/4857703/a-distinct-human-organism

4.       Dr. Anthony Levatino Addresses Congress: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=53tzMV9OmvY (4:20 mark addresses abortion to save the life of the mother)

5.       Planned Parenthood, “What Is Ectopic Pregnancy? | Definition and Treatment”

https://www.plannedparenthood.org/learn/pregnancy/ectopic-pregnancy

6.       Real Choices Clinic, “Ectopic Pregnancy Treatment is Not Abortion”

https://realchoicesclinic.com/helpful-advice/ectopic-pregnancy-treatment-is-not-an-abortion

Sunday, August 7, 2016

The Argument (for the existence of God) from Objective Morality - Does Qualia Soup defeat it?



The Argument from Objective Morality is one of the most popular arguments for the existence of God that is used by Christian apologists.  The youtube site “Qualia Soup”, hereafter referred to as just QS, has a 3 part video series on morality.  Part 1 is on evils committed by religious people and Part 2 is on the evils of “religious books”.  Both of these can be responded to and I may do so in future articles but my focus here will be on the argument from objective morality and only Part 3 deals with it.

The Argument from Objective Morality is explained in this video:

The argument is as follows:
1. If God does not exist, objective moral values and duties do not exist.
2. Objective moral values and duties do exist.
3. Therefore, God exists.

The 3 part video series by QS can be found here:

Part 3, which I will be evaluating, begins at the 27:48 mark.

QS does not dispute the logical validity of the argument – that is that the conclusion (3) necessarily follows from the premises (1 and 2) if they are true.  QS goes after both 1 and 2 to show they are not or cannot be true.

QS argument against objective values
QS, first, deals with the definition of objective moral values, as used by prominent Christian apologist Dr. William Lane Craig, hereafter referred to as WLC.  The definition that WLC uses is that to say that something has objective moral value is to say that it has good or bad value independent of whether anyone believes it to be so.  It would be to say that it is not a result of opinion, which would be subjective.

QS argues against this idea by saying that if two people perform an action with one thinking it evil and the other having no sense of evil (i.e. they are ignorant of it) we don’t accept their harmful behavior but we don’t call it evil.  That is not true.  In our society the acts are still deemed as evil acts but the punishment may be altered given a person’s ignorance of the crime, possibly for reasons called insanity.  Murder is still deemed murder but may carry a lesser degree in the sentence.1 

QS also argues that if good and evil are independent of anyone’s beliefs about it then it is unintelligible.  QS states “To say that some things have unevaluated value becomes unintelligible”.  Should we believe that statement to be true?  Are things true or false only if they can be evaluated?  I don’t think so.  Consider 2+2=4.  Would that mathematical statement be true even if nobody ever thought about it?  I think it would.  QS may object and say that evaluating math concepts and moral concepts cannot be treated the same.  Why not?  Suppose the world was coming to an end and there was just one person left.  Would the idea that it would be wrong to murder still be true?  I think so.  Despite the inability to carry out a murderous act or even think about it, it would still be a wrong act.

WLC points out in his presentation of the Argument from Objective Morals that the animal kingdom is morally neutral (amoral).  When one animal kills another it kills it but it does not murder it.  It has done no evil act.  If humans are just more advanced species than the rest of the animals, to think humans actions have good or bad value would then be a demonstration of speciesism.  QS objects, stating, “our greater capacity for moral reflection is not ‘unjustifiable bias’.  It is a relevant difference”.  This seems to miss the point though.  Our greater capacity for moral reflection is an issue of epistemology (i.e. how we come to know things) but the Argument from Objective Morality is about ontology (i.e. the existence of things).  WLC’s point is that if the animal kingdom is amoral and humans are just more advanced via evolution then why should we not think humans are amoral as well if there is no objective standard?

QS argues that values come from “what we judge morally valuable or important”.  This concept, when actually carried out, has led to some of the most oppressive and destructive societies the world has ever seen.  History is full of societies that have abused various sects of people because the ruling party did not deem others to be morally valuable or important.  A subjective base for morality is dangerous.

QS argues that “given ‘Sufficiently specified standards’ – It will be an objective issue…how well any particular specimen measures up to those standards.  The choice of standards is not objective but is not arbitrary.”  This is just moving the target.  Objectively determining if a non-objective standard is measured up to works fine when we are talking about how well an athlete performs in a given set of rules for an athletic event but when the playing field is the moral landscape of humanity it doesn’t get one out of the problems of a subjective framework – problems which would be that it is left to majority rule or most powerful rule.  QS rightly points out that majority rule or most powerful rule does not establish an objective moral framework.  In fact, within the athletic analogy we only need to look at instances where a player has not only committed a foul within the rule of the given game they are in but also stepped out of bounds of the moral standard.  Society does not view their actions as having just violated a current subjective standard but that they have done something that is wrong period!  For example, when Metta World Peace (aka Ron Artest) elbowed a player in the head in a playoff game it was viewed as something that was wrong, not just in the game but in life.2  For the Oklahoma City fans it was probably equivalent to the unpardonable sin.  I, being a long time Laker fan, was able to forgive him. :)

QS argument against objective duties
QS’s first objection to objective moral duties is the same as one of its objections to objective moral values – that if it exists independent of any persons knowledge then it is unintelligible, or in this case QS says that it “has no purchase”.  My response to that objection is the same as my response in the objective values section above.  Here QS says that as our knowledge increases our understanding of our moral duties may change.  QS establishes a measuring device here – a “protective attitude”.  But why think this “protective attitude” is a duty or something a moral duty should sprout from?  The Argument from Objective Morality posits a reason why we could use a “protective attitude” as a measuring device but absent an objective morality it is just arbitrary.  Some may argue that it is reasoned to but if it involves reasoning to a subjective standard, it is still at its roots, arbitrary.

QS refers to David Hume to state that we can’t get an “ought” from an “is”.  That is a statement that Christian apologists agree with.  QS continues, though, to illustrate Hume’s view that evil isn’t a feature of murder but a judgement arising from sentiment.3  Supposing a non-objective framework I would agree with Hume that this is what it would have to be – sentiment.  It would just be a feeling but nothing really evil about murder and that feeling could vary from person to person.  But is that how we treat murder?  No, we treat it as if it is really wrong – not just a feeling for some people.

QS states that “If I want others to not hurt me”, “to avoid hypocrisy”, “this obliges me not to hurt them”.  This is a behavior rule we can all agree with but it still does not set a right and wrong.  In fact, it is saying that it is not really wrong to hurt someone unless you want to avoid hypocrisy but that just moves the question of why, given a non-objective framework, is it wrong to hurt someone to the question of why, given a non-objective framework, is it wrong to be a hypocrite?  QS says that this is a preference and that when we dissect all moral obligations we find some element of preference.  Is this true?  If we assume a non-objective framework then, yes, it is necessarily true - but what about God as an objective foundation for morals?  Morals as part of the nature of an uncreated, necessary being would not be based on a preference.

QS notes WLC’s use of St. Anselm’s concept of God as the ‘greatest conceivable being’.  Here QS goes on to make a refute of Anselm’s Ontological Argument but WLC does not use the Ontological argument as part of the reasoning in the Argument from Objective Morality.  WLC simply uses the ‘greatest conceivable being’ concept as the definition of God and we can reason to what some of the necessary qualities would be for this ‘greatest conceivable being’. 

We can actually start with premise two of the Argument from Objective Morality – if it is true then we can responsibly ask what would be required for this objective standard to exist.  It would require that it not be an opinion; it could not be arbitrary; it would have to be unchanging; it would have to be necessary; we could even rightfully argue that it would have to be good in nature.  All of these are qualities commonly attributed to God so that if objective morals actually exist then it would follow that God must exist.

QS then makes an argument that if we had to choose a model for morals it wouldn’t be the God of “ancient scriptures” since that God “violates principles we hold to be most basic”.  What are these “most basic” principles if not an objective standard?  It seems that in trying to defeat an objective standard QS is appealing to one.  Furthermore, ancient scriptures such as The Bible are irrelevant to the Argument from Objective Morality.  While I believe The Bible to be true and The word of God and a good source to learn morals from and that it can be defended; it is not part of this argument and can be dealt with elsewhere.

I have not addressed point by point each of QS’s arguments but I believe what I have refuted covers them all, i.e. in some cases an individual refute of mine covered multiple points by QS.  I believe the Argument from Objective Morality remains a valid and strong argument for the existence of God.

At the end of the video QS states a part 4 will be coming out that will explain the “origins and components of a more well rounded morality”.  I searched for that video but could not find it on the QS youtube site.
Notes

3.       I did not take the time to review Hume’s statements that QS refers to.  It sounds correct to my recollection but if it is not, my response is to QS’s presentation of Hume’s views and not necessarily Hume’s view if they differ.

Bill Clute is the Greenville, SC chapter director for Reasonable Faith.  He works as an IT professional with a degree in Computer Systems from the University of North Carolina-Asheville where he was also a member of the basketball team.  He has also been a professional airshow pilot and now flies a plane which was built from scratch by he and his father.

Saturday, February 23, 2013

Does God Exist?

Dr. Craig presents 3 reasons why life would be meaningless without God and 5 arguments for the existence of God:
http://www.reasonablefaith.org/does-god-exist-1

How do I know that Christianity is right out of all the worlds religions?

Are all religions the same?  Does it matter what you believe?  Is it intolerant to believe there is only one way to ultimate truth?  J.P. Moreland addresses these issues:
http://www.bethinking.org/spirituality/intermediate/how-do-we-know-christianity-is-right-out-of-all-the-religions.htm

Here Michael Ramsden tackles the same topic, expaining how the Christian message is unique in what it says and what it accomplishes:
http://www.rzim.org/let-my-people-think-broadcasts/one-god-many-paths/

Jesus is not a created being or a lesser god but is God

This article lays out the evidence for the Trinitarian God - i.e. 1 God made up of 3 persons: Father, Son and Holy Spirit.  This is a foundational belief for Christianity.

http://www.bethinking.org/who-are-you-god/intermediate/the-historic-case-for-the-trinity.htm

Here is a quick reference to Biblical scriptures that point to a Trinitarian God:
http://billcluteairshows.com/Trinity.html

Friday, February 1, 2013

Evidence for the Existence of the Soul

Is man only matter?  Do we have an immaterial property?  J.P. Moreland breaks down the evidence for the existence of the soul.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FWjkbNkMiMo