Biblical Analysis of scriptures used in abortion
arguments
Scriptures used for the Pro-Choice argument
Exodus
21:22-23 This passage presents a scenario where two men are fighting
and a pregnant woman is accidentally struck. The woman is not hurt but
depending on the translation the baby is either the victim of a miscarriage or
born premature but alive. The Hebrew word in question here is yasa
and means to go or come out. Frequently, yasa is used in the Old
Testament to render a live birth. This may be irrelevant to this argument
since this scripture is not referring to an intentional act of killing the
unborn. Those that use this scripture to support a pro-choice argument
usually say that verse 23 shows that the unborn are not given the same rights
as those outside of the womb. This understanding would require the
translation of yasa as a miscarriage or abortion but since verse 22
clearly depicts an accident it wouldn’t be a murder but simply an accident or
an equivalent of involuntary manslaughter which doesn’t carry the same penalty
as murder. It is not a statement on the value or rights of a person but
instead a statement on the intentions of those that caused the event.
Jeremiah
20:14-18 In this passage Jeremiah is lamenting that he was ever born.
He expresses a wish that he had been aborted, having his mother’s womb as his
grave. The error in using this as scripture for pro-choice is that it
assumes that an expression desiring that one had been aborted is declaration
that abortion is morally permitted but this text doesn’t go that far. He
wonders why he was born just to end his life in shame but we know that
Jeremiah’s life did not end in shame. His reason for desiring that he had
been aborted was shown to be wrong. What this scripture does do, though,
is speak of the unborn as a person.
Ecclesiastes
6:3-5 and Job
3:16-19 Like the passage from Jeremiah we have an account of a person
lamenting life and questioning if it is better to never have been born. This
does not promote or support abortion but questions whether or not it can be
better to never have been born than to not be able to enjoy the fruits of life
or find rest and security from the wicked.
Numbers
5:11-31 This passage is about a test to determine if a wife has been
unfaithful. The test consists of drinking a potion and the effect the potion
has on the wife will determine if she was guilty. There really was nothing “magical” about the
potion. The priests knew that it would
be God that would be revealing guilt or non-guilt, not the potion. If she was not guilty she would be unaffected
and able to conceive children. If she
was guilty the penalty would be that “her belly would swell and her thigh will
shrivel”. That seems to be some sort of
euphemism. It seems to mean that she
will become sick and no longer be capable of conceiving children. That was her curse. That would seem to be a conclusion consistent
with the statement in the passage that if she was not guilty she would be able
to conceive children. All the
translations I can find translate it this way except one – the NIV. It says that the potion will cause the guilty
to have a miscarriage. From that some
people find an angle to make this about abortion. That seems to be out of line
though. The passage never says the woman
was even pregnant. This was about
finding if the wife was guilty of infidelity, regardless of whether or not she
got pregnant from it.
Scriptures used for the Pro-Life argument
Psalm 22:10,
Luke 1:15 and Luke 1:41 These
verses are used by some pro-life advocates to show the personhood of the unborn
in the womb. I do not think that is the intent the Psalmist or Luke
had. These verses seem to me to be figurative and\or hyperbolic speech.
Exodus 20:13
This is the command from the 10 commandments against murder. I do believe
abortion is murder but I do not believe this verse can be used as an argument
against abortion unless the unborn in the womb is first shown to be a live
human. I believe this can be done using
my argument from human rights but I don’t think that the scripture by itself stands
as an argument against abortion. [see my article “Abortion – an unnecessary
violation of human rights”]
Although I do not believe we have scripture that directly
addresses abortion I do believe we can find the views of the earliest Christian
church by writings outside of the Bible. For example, The Didache, a
Christian writing dated to the 1st century states “you shall not
murder a child by abortion”.